Showing posts with label integrated amplifier. Show all posts
Showing posts with label integrated amplifier. Show all posts

Saturday, May 3, 2008

Marantz PM-11S1 Integrated Amplifier Review

HI-FI, Sterio, Home Theater, Audiophile, Amplifier, Speaker

I drive a simple vehicle. It's a 2003 Jeep Liberty and I like it a lot. If I were offered the opportunity, however, to test drive a Hummer or Porsche Carrera - I'd do it in a heartbeat. Why? Because I'm not likely to fork out that kind of money in my lifetime and it's occasionally nice to see "how the other guy lives". The Marantz PM-11S1 is my Porsche Carrera this month. At a price tag of over $4k I'm not going to be able to afford to keep this baby in my reference system for long, but it is a superb machine with all the styling of a European sports car. It's the kind of product you don't want to leave fingerprints on and will find yourself taking extra time to install it into your system - not because it can't be manhandled or take the abuse, but because - like a fine work of art - you don't want to diminish its beauty in any way.

Build Quality

PM-11S1 insidesThe PM-11S1 is nearly impossible to open up, but we were able to get a look at the internal components and see what makes this ~60 lb beast tick. Of first note, the entire chassis is champagne-finished and copper-plated. And I mean it is PLATED. Even the chassis screws are copper - making for a very rugged, yet elegant, look. The PM-11S1 utilizes fully balanced pre-amplifier section, which doesn't just slap on XLR inputs and route neutral to ground. The dual mono-block power amplifier design assures that the unit can operate in either stereo or mono "bi-amplification" mode. I suppose if you don't feel one of these monsters is enough for your system you can always grab another. The PM-11S1 also employs Marantz' new HDAM® SA2 system. HDAM stands for Hyper Dynamic Amplifier Module, an ultra high-speed buffer amplifier that can operate at 0 dB unity gain with an unparalleled slew rate of 200 V/micro-second. These buffers are on all inputs and outputs of the unit. This is a proprietary technology developed by Marantz to ensure smooth signal transfer to and from the PM-11S1.

The volume is controlled by a Wolfson WM8816 high-precision linear system and a floating control bus system allows multiple units to be synchronized for use in a multi-channel environment. Even the LCD display is designed with zero noise technology to ensure nothing interferes with the sound output.

Editorial Note: Under the Hood
This amp has it where it counts. The PM-11S1 inherits its design from the venerated SC-7S1/MA-9S1 preamplifier/monaural power amplifier separates of days passed. It features a massive hybrid toroidal transformer which takes up residence towards the front of the unit, just behind the input selection knob. Marantz, not particularly concerned with size reduction or cost, opted to utilize a choke input system power supply circuit to increase power factor (real power) of the system. This amplifier is designed to "double down" - doubling its output as the loudspeaker impedance drops.

The interior layout of this integrated amplifier is magnificent, with huge heatsinks radiating out from the center, and sandwiched carefully between the ventilated top and bottom covers. This allows for optimal heat dispersal and is the reason this behemoth requires no internal fan system. Two large capacitors and the remaining electronics circuitry fill the remaining space. Airflow is primarily vertical through this amplifier, since there isn't a lot of wasted space within the chassis itself.

Fit, Finish and Connections

PM-11S1-hero.jpgMoving once again to the exterior of the unit, the front panel has a beautiful brushed aluminum finish, in the aforementioned champagne color. This is something special that really stands out in a crowd, but in a way that will have you figuring out how to acquire the rest of Marantz' Reference series components to not break up the look of your system. The volume and input selection knobs feel rugged and allow you to turn them without feeling like you will break them off. Buttons are firm but easily accessible, and the centrally-located power button is nicely recessed against accidental activation.

There is a nice blue backlighting on the main unit that serves to illuminate the primary buttons in a subtle, yet appealing manner. In addition, the lower three buttons on each side of the raised central panel have tiny central blue LEDs that light up enough to access the button, but not enough to blind you in a darkened room (these don't go off when the Display function is set to 'off'). Overall it's one of the nicer looking lighted systems I've seen - unobtrusive and elegant.

Taking a look at the rear of the Marantz PM-11S1 will show off the high-quality WBT-style 5-way binding posts. These are the top of the line and make it very easy to connect your speaker cables, regardless of type (banana, spade, etc). There are 'A' and 'B' speaker connections, but these are primarily for use with bi-wiring. If you have well-made speakers cables that are 10- or 12-gauge you shouldn't need to bi-wire. The rear of the unit is well laid-out, with ample room for maneuvering your fingers where they need to be in order to make connections and get all of your equipment connected properly. I liked the simple vertical structure which laid out all of the inputs in a nice row, with the outputs located in a separate column. The balanced XLR inputs (which I utilized with Logitech's new Transporter network music player) are located on their own, above the outputs, with ample room for making the connections.

PM-11S1-inputs.jpg

As is evident from this rear photo, there isn't much to confuse users here. Six (6) analogue RCA stereo inputs, a stereo XLR balanced input and 3 line level outputs (including a preamp out) make up the bulk of the back panel. Note that phono inputs are provided - which is key since this system is definitely targeting audiophiles who may still cling to their LP collection like a cat on a screen door. On the right side of the unit users will see the switch for using the system in bi-amp mode (assumes you have two or more of these integrated amplifiers in your system) as well as the Floating Control Bus System (F.C.B.S.) Unlike other things that end with "B.S." this is actually a useful feature when using two or more PM-11S1a in your system as it allows you to have a 'master' unit and control the slaves via a single remote.

Related Links...

Read More...

Denon AVR-5805 Press Release

Denon AVR-5805 Press Release Denon AVR-5805 Press Release Denon AVR-5805 Press Release Denon AVR-5805 Press Release Denon AVR-5805 Press Release HI-FI, Sterio, Home Theater, Audiophile, Amplifier, Speaker

Denon Electronics, the industry's leading manufacturer of high-quality home theater receivers, today introduced the AVR-5805 audio/video receiver, an unprecedented single-component solution that lets users enjoy a distributed four-zone home theater entertainment experience. Featuring 16-channels of output capability and fully assignable 10 discrete amplifiers, the AVR-5805 is the world's first A/V receiver capable of providing multi-zone 5.1 system capability. Denon will be exhibiting the AVR-5805 in Booth #351.

Multi-Source, Multi-Zone Flexibility
The AVR-5805 offers custom installers and home entertainment enthusiasts the first-ever high-performance alternative to multi-component distributed audio/video systems. The AVR-5805 can accommodate both audio and video from up to four independent sources and distribute them to four separate zones in the home. Through its ten fully discrete 170-watt amplifiers and comprehensive processing capabilities, the AVR-5805 provides integrators and end users with outstanding setup and operation options, such as:

  • One full 9.1-channel surround sound system in a single room;
  • Two discrete 5.1-channel systems in different rooms;
  • One 7.1-channel system in the main zone, with a 2.1-channel system in a second room and a mono system in a third room;
  • An audiophile-oriented "bi-amp" mode, with two amplifiers used for each front, left, right and center speaker or for a full 5-channel system, delivering maximum power and performance.

Adding convenience and flexibility to multi-zone operation, the AVR-5805 features independent volume control of each zone, as well as discrete selection. In addition, power to any or all of the zones can be turned on or shut off independently to conserve power consumption if a zone is not in use.

img class="image-right" src="http://www.audioholics.com/audioholics/images/denon5805receiverrear_th.jpg" alt="Denon AVR-5805 receiver rear" height="155" width="250" /> Advanced Video Conversion and Scaling 
The AVR-5805 features a host of today's most advanced video conversion and scaling technologies, including the world's first discrete 2-zone video conversion capability and HDTV switching. Component video up-conversion automatically converts S-video or composite video input signals from sources such as DVD players, VCRs or camcorders, to a high-quality component video signal. In addition, Time Based Correction is employed in the video conversion circuitry to permit better compatibility and performance from all video sources. The AVR-5805 also includes built-in video scaling using a Faroudja integrated processor with DCDi (Directional Correlational Deinterlacing) technology and 12 bit/216 MHz video DACs to up convert interlaced 480i sources to 480p, 720p and 1080i. Uncompromised Audio Performance The AVR-5805 features an Equal Power amplifier section that delivers a massive 170 watts of high-current power into each of its ten channels, and is compatible with every popular 6.1- and 5.1-channel surround sound format, from Dolby, dts and Dolby Pro Logic IIx to THX Ultra2 Cinema and Music, and THX Surround EX decoding. It also features THX 4.0/5.1/6.1 post processing, and offers additional and useful DSP modes. Audio performance is maximized through Denon's newly improved DDSC-D (Dynamic Discrete Surround Decoder-Digital) and Advanced AL24 Processing circuitry, which utilizes the use of advanced Texas Instruments and Analog Devices 32-bit floating point processors and Burr-Brown 24-bit/192kHz audio DACs.

In addition, the AVR-5805 offers the most extensive complement of connection options of any receiver in the industry, including 3 HDMI and 1 DVI-D digital video ports; 6 high-bandwidth (100 MHz), HDTV-compatible component video inputs (including dual component video monitoring for the main zone), IEEE-1394, a total of 14 audio/video inputs, connections for 2 high-resolution audio sources, such as DVD-A or SACD, multiple RS-232C ports, Ethernet and much more.

New Auto Set-Up/Room EQ: A "Sweet Spot" For Every Listener
The AVR-5805's state-of-the-art Auto Set-Up and Room Correction feature go well beyond conventional room calibration methods, and makes it possible to completely customize the listening experience for any room. The AVR-5805 incorporates a new room correction and calibration technology called Audyssey -3- MultEQ™ XT from Audyssey Laboratories. It is the first such technology capable of minimizing the effects of room acoustics for multiple listeners. During Auto Set-Up MultEQ XT automatically determines how many loudspeakers are connected, whether they are connected in phase, and whether they are satellites or subwoofers. It then analyzes and calibrates speaker level, size, and distance. In addition, MultEQ XT detects the proper crossover point and determines correct frequency response for up to eight listener positions simultaneously. It creates an optimized soundfield and compensates for speaker and room capabilities. So there is a "sweet spot" for every listener or viewer, no matter where in the room they're sitting.

Denon's implementation of MultEQ XT utilizes multiple Aureus high-performance DSP processors from Texas Instruments, along with the finest Digital to Analog converters, to define optimum sound quality. Additionally, both the Room EQ and Auto Set-Up features can be disabled for installers and consumers who prefer to calibrate their receivers in the traditional manner.

New Advanced Video and Audio Circuitry
Key to the AVR-5805's superlative video and audio performance is the inclusion of several new and/or improved Denon technologies. For example, the receiver features the newest version of Denon's Dynamic Discrete Surround Circuit (DDSC), which features a 192 kHz processing circuit and the latest 32-bit floating point DSPs for both the main and second zones, resulting in the highest level of audio accuracy. The receiver's remarkable surround sound capabilities are further enhanced by innovations such as Burr-Brown PCM-1792 24-bit/192kHz audio DACs for all 16 channels. Yet another Denon exclusive adds to the AVR-5805's exquisite sound reproduction capabilities, namely Advanced AL24 Processing on all channels. Advanced AL24 maximizes all source signals so that the high-resolution DA converters work at their highest capacity.

Custom Installation-Friendly Features, Plus Upgradeability
In addition to its extensive complement of digital and analog audio and video connections, the AVR-5805 also includes a full array of custom installation A/V receiver features, such as assignable high current DC trigger outputs (4) and a pair of RS-232C ports to facilitate not only integrated system operation, but for PC connectivity for system setup. Also included is the latest version of Denon Link 3, which allows the receiver to receive high-resolution, multi-channel digital audio data directly from the Denon DVD-5900 and DVD-3910 DVD players (and future Denon products) for the ultimate level of sonic performance.

Denon Link 3 is compatible with all previously released Denon Link products, but is now ready to accept digital SACD data from future Denon source units, if and when formal approval is granted. Finally, thanks to its built-in Ethernet port, the receiver offers TCP/IP control capability, and can accommodate any future software/firmware upgrades. The AVR-5805 is also supplied with a new, improved EL programmable remote control.

The Denon AVR-5805 will be available in November for a suggested retail price of $6,000.

Related Links...

Read More...

Friday, May 2, 2008

Harman/Kardon AVR 340 7.1 A/V Receiver

Harman/Kardon AVR 340 7.1 A/V Receiver Harman/Kardon AVR 340 7.1 A/V Receiver Harman/Kardon AVR 340 7.1 A/V Receiver Harman/Kardon AVR 340 7.1 A/V Receiver Harman/Kardon AVR 340 7.1 A/V Receiver Harman/Kardon AVR 340 7.1 A/V Receiver Harman/Kardon AVR 340 7.1 A/V Receiver Harman/Kardon AVR 340 7.1 A/V Receiver Harman/Kardon AVR 340 7.1 A/V Receiver Harman/Kardon AVR 340 7.1 A/V Receiver HI-FI, Sterio, Home Theater, Audiophile, Amplifier, Speaker

Harman/Kardon historically has been a brand that produced quality components. I remember being awed as a youth at a family friend's rig that included high end H/K equipment. Not only did it perform, but it looked cool as well.

In the last several years, they have added entry and mid-level products to their lineup. The Harman/Kardon AVR 340 receiver is a mid-level unit that includes some excellent features for the MSRP of $899, and a street price even lower. I took it for an extensive test drive, and found a lot to like.

Set-up

Upon un-boxing the unit and putting it on my shelf, the AVR 340 instantly appealed to me. It conforms to Harman/Kardon's current two-toned style and svelte, minimalist look. The front panel features a blue electroluminescent readout accompanied by blue backlit logos for the various surround and DSP modes as well as the currently active speakers. To top it off, the volume knob is lined with a glowing blue light. As should be the case, you can either dim the display or turn it off completely. The bottom line is that this receiver looks great.

I made all of my standard connections, including my HD DVR, HTPC, SACD, and DVD players. The AVR 340 has a multitude of inputs, though no DVI or HDMI. It has two component video ports (I would have preferred to see three at this price point) and will up-convert all video signals to component output. In addition, it will send the on-screen menus over the component outputs, which I found to be particularly handy in that I only needed to run one cable from the receiver to my projector. However, the currently selected source must be 480i/p, as the 340 cannot overlay its display onto a higher resolution format.

The manual recommends certain device types be plugged into the first three video inputs as those device types are pre-programmed into the remote. However, you can label any input in any manner you choose, so if you do not plan on using the included remote control as your universal remote, you need not worry about where you plug in which device. For each input, you can actually give it any label you choose. You have access to a full list of alphanumeric characters. The benefits of this are obvious.

The AVR 340 also has 7.1 analog inputs most likely to be used by for SACD, DVD-Audio, HD-DVD, or Blu-ray player. These inputs have become standard on A/V receivers, mostly because of the next-generation audio formats that have not reallly taken off yet. However, with the next-generation video disc formats, the digital sound format decoding process has moved back to the player from the receiver (at least for the short term). The new surround formats such as Dolby TrueHD, Dolby Digital Plus, and DTS-HD cannot be decoded by any receivers at the moment. Thus, the limited number of players that are out there can do some of this decoding, but must pass the resulting discrete audio channels to the receiver either via HDMI (using uncompressed PCM), or by analog RCA cables. In the end, the analog inputs that were included in current receivers by and large for DVD-Audio and SACD have found new life due to HD-DVD and Blu-Ray. Of course, whether or not these disc formats will suffer the same fate as their audio brethren has yet to be seen.

Once connected and configured, it was time to try out the EzSet/EQ automatic speaker configuration program. Such a feature was limited to higher-end receivers only a year ago, and it is a welcome sight to see it trickle down into the more moderately priced models. I attached the supplied omni-directional microphone included with the 340 and began the set-up routines. After a couple of minutes, it was finished. I reviewed the settings and found them to be quite accurate. It identified all of my speakers as small, which is correct; and the distances were good as well. It did set my center and surround channels to a 100 Hz crossover, which I adjusted down to 80 Hz. To compare, I manually configured the 340 with my SPL meter and the Avia Home Theater set-up DVD. I found the few differences to be all by 1 dB up or down except for the sub, which was 2 dB louder with the auto-configuration. Each input has its own speaker configuration settings that can be saved. However, I prefer to begin with them all having the same baseline configuration, and then, if possible, adjust with source material played through each input. Overall, I was very pleased with the results of the Harman/Kardon auto-configuration.

One set-up issue I did have with this unit was that when playing a source with a digital audio connection, as soon as a new surround format was detected in the digital bit-stream, the receiver would quickly switch to that format. For example, if I set the AVR 340 to Dolby Digital + PLIIx (meaning it uses the Dolby Digital signal for the discrete 5.1 channels, and then derives the two rear surround channels from the two main surrounds), and then played a DVD with a Dolby Digital track, it would switch back to pure Dolby Digital and the two rear surrounds would be turned off. This annoyed me quite a bit, but upon further examination of the manual I found that this is actually a feature in the advanced options menu called "Default Surround Mode". Basically, engaging this setting will cause the 340 to default to whatever surround mode is detected on the currently playing input.

If you put in a DVD with a Dolby Digital EX soundtrack it will automatically switch to that mode. However, if you prefer that additional processing of Pro Logic IIx, you need to turn this feature off if you don't want to manually switch to that mode every time a Dolby Digital EX signal is detected. I would have preferred for this to be the default behavior, as it is with my everyday receiver, but once I found this setting and turned it off, all was well.

Interesting and Unique Features

The HK340 has an excellent feature set for this class of receiver. In addition to the already covered AutoEQ, it has some some other great attributes that had previously been found on only higher-end units. Being in the Harman International group does have its benefits. As a cousin to the Lexicon family, the AVR 3430 has their proprietary Logic 7 processing. Much like Dolby Pro Logic II/IIx, or DTS Neo:6, Logic 7 takes a two-channel signal and derives either 5.1 or 7.1 channels of audio to create a full surround sound experience. I had wanted to hear Logic 7 processing for some time, and was excited to try it out. Since the competing formats came out several years ago, I have found that I prefer Pro Logic IIx processing to DTS Neo:6 for basically all sources that require such multi-channel extrapolation, but I hadn't yet heard Logic 7 in action.

The H/K limits you as to your surround formats based on what signal it detects. For instance, you cannot apply Logic 7 processing to a signal encoded with DTS or Dolby Digital. The receiver also features a mode called VMax, which creates a surround effect using just the two front speakers. There is both a near and far setting to create a smaller and more spacious effect, respectively. Dolby Headphone settings are also included.

Another great feature that many custom installers will appreciate is the second zone functionality. Included in the package is a small remote for controlling the second zone. You can attach a remote IR input to the receiver and drive two channels in the remote zone. Of course, if you choose to use to do this, you sacrifice internal amplification of the rear surround channels. You can add a separate two channel amplifier and output your second zone L/R channels to it via standard RCA connections. The 340 also is A-Bus compatible and can connect to such systems via Category 5/5e cabling with RJ-45 jacks.

One of the most interesting features of this receiver is the ability to plug in what H/K calls the "Bridge". Basically, it is a docking cradle for an Apple iPod that interfaces with the receiver so you can both control the iPod with the receiver's remote and also see what is playing on the receiver's display. Additionally, you have the option to let the 340 charge the iPod while it is docked. This is a very cool feature for those with the popular portable music jukebox (which, according to market share statistics, includes quite a few of you!).

The cradle fits all iPods that have a docking connector. It includes inserts for the cradle that create a snug fit for the iPod. There was no insert for my Nano at the time they sent me the Bridge, yet it would still lock into place on the dock and work perfectly. I am sure they now include such an insert. I have worked with several different types of home audio servers and network connected systems, and there are definitely advantages to that type of setup. However, one cool little trick about docking an iPod is that if you are out and about, and create an on-the-go playlist that you want to hear right away when you get home, all you have to do is pop the iPod into the cradle and select that playlist. Since the connection is via the dock connector, there is little, if any, loss of sound quality when playing the iPod in this fashion. Sure, it is most likely already in a compressed format such as MP3 or AAC, but it is still a superior method of connecting your iPod to your quality receiver than using the headphone jack. All in all, being able to integrate the iPod into your home theater is becoming a popular option among mid- and upper-level receivers, and is a very useful feature for the millions of people who have one.

Performance

Putting this receiver through its paces was quite an enjoyable experience. My normal receiver is rated at 120w per channel into seven channels. The 340 is rated at 55w into seven channels, so I was interested to see how the apparently large power difference would manifest itself.

One important point to note is actually found on Harman/Kardon's website. The power rating specs are based on driving all channels simultaneously, which many companies do not take into account when publishing amplifier specs. While I couldn't drive my system to the levels I can with my regular receiver, the H/K put out plenty of juice for my normal viewing habits.

I began with a few of my favorite reference DVDs. The Two Towers Extended Director's Cut is perhaps my favorite movie from the series, and the added material not only contributes greatly to the storyline, but provides an extra 30 minutes of candy for the ears and eyes. I sampled several scenes with both the Dolby Digital and DTS tracks. Applying the Pro Logic IIx processing to the Dolby Digital signal, thereby creating 7.1 discrete channels, was simply outstanding. I preferred this mix to the DTS one, oddly enough. It was more enveloping and realistic to me. The 340 played loud, clearly, and cleanly, with no distortion at reference levels. The pounding of the Ent footsteps reverberated with power, as did their speech. Later, I felt as if I was right in the middle of the climactic battle at Helm's Deep as the arrows whizzed by my ears.

Next I put in The Matrix Reloaded from the 10 disc Ultimate Matrix Collection. The freeway scene is both aurally and visually beautiful. The H/K reproduced the soundtrack with fine crispness and detail. The hum of the crotch rocket's engine as Trinity and the Keymaker tried to escape pulsed through my theater. The supernatural whizzing of the bladed weapons as Neo fought off the Merovingian's henchmen sounded light yet deadly.

Testing with some music finally allowed me to experience Logic 7, and thus let me compare it directly with DTS: Neo 6 and Dolby Pro Logic IIx. I suppose I could have tested it with the two- channel soundtrack from any DVD as well, but since I rarely watch a film and select the two-channel audio track, I felt that music would be a better real world test for me. Sure, there are plenty of films that don't have a surround mix, but in those cases, I would rather watch it with its stereo track anyway (instead of extracting a surround experience where none was intended). I will also state for the record, that using the dedicated eight-channel input with some SACDs proved that the amplifier stages of the receiver were of excellent quality. I could not hear any clipping or distortion at high levels, and clarity and depth were still apparent at low levels.

I listened to several different types of music, employing the Logic 7, seven-channel music mode. I must say that in my opinion, Logic 7 surpasses the Pro Logic IIx and DTS:Neo 6 methods for creating surround from two channels of audio. I still think Dolby does an excellent job, but Logic 7 was a more realistic and natural sounding experience. One of the best examples of this during my listening was on the track "Can't Find My Way Home" from the classic album/band Blind Faith. In the instrumental passage towards the end of the track, there is a loud crash of a cymbal. While listening with Pro Logic IIx engaged, the sound came at me directly and somewhat harshly from the left surround speaker. With Logic 7 activated, the cymbal did not sound so directional; rather, it was woven more naturally into the left front part of the overall soundstage.

Generally, Logic 7 seemed to sound more true to the original source material while still providing an enveloping sound experience. It is a natural evolution in surround sound. Remember when you first heard a receiver that could create a concert hall effect and you were wowed? Well, now I would venture to guess most people completely ignore those faux venue creations since they carry with them the problems inherent in those very locations! Would you rather sit down to listen to music that has been artificially enhanced with reverberation that you didn't want in the first place? Of course not! Now surround formats such as Logic 7 and Dolby Pro Logic IIx demonstrate a more mature intent to subtly enhance the dimension and envelopment of the sound, rather than call attention to them as enhancement.

While 98% of my experience with the 340 was positive, there were a couple of issues I ran into with the unit. One somewhat substantial problem I had was how it output 480p material to my Sony VPL-HS10 projector. When I fired up my Nintendo GameCube and told it to output a progressive image, the projector really had trouble syncing to the input. The video would constantly drop out. I have never had problems with this when switching the video through my everyday receiver, or when connecting the GameCube directly to the HS10. I confirmed it to be a problem with the 340 as I set my Moxi cable DVR to 480p output as well and experienced the same dropouts. I can't be sure if this is a flaw with my specific unit, but it definitely posed a problem for connecting my 480p source devices.

A common complaint I see in many receiver reviews is with the remote control, and unfortunately, this review is no exception. I am continually mystified as to how companies can design great receivers and yet provide such a poor human interface to them! The battery compartment is located at the top of the somewhat long remote, and thus it feels top heavy in my hand. The remote narrows from top to bottom, which makes for an awkward experience when accessing the bottom-most buttons.

The button layout has pros and cons. The volume buttons share the exact same shape as the sleep timer and DSP surround select buttons, and I often found myself accidentally setting the receiver to turn off in 90 minutes rather than adjusting the sound. The button to turn on the on-screen menus (which aren't required, but definitely provide an easier interface to adjust settings than the front display) is hidden among similarly sized buttons that are rarely used. Of course, my biggest gripe with buttons on a remote like this is that the keys are not backlit, or even glow-in-the-dark. I watch movies and such in the dark, as I am sure a majority of home theater enthusiasts do, and it drives me batty when I have to turn the lights up to find the function I want. On the positive side, I like the four-way navigation controller with a selection key in the middle of the remote. This makes scrolling through and selecting menu items a breeze. I also like how Harman/Kardon tried to include as many functions as they could on the remote so there is not a constant need to wade through menus or multiple key presses to perform simple tasks.

The remote is programmable and does come preloaded with many codes, but it is still no match for a good universal model.

My final reservation about the 340 is simply the amount of heat it generates. There is an active fan on the back of the unit as well as the standard vents to draw heat out, but the top of the receiver is very hot to the touch. You definitely want to have adequate headroom in your rack for the 340 or you may be asking for trouble.

Conclusions

My overall opinion of this receiver is quite a positive one. Once I became accustomed to using the 340, I realized what a wonderful fit it was in my home theater. Keep in mind, if you are an avid iPod user, this is an excellent choice with which to integrate it into in your home system.

I definitely enjoyed test driving the AVR 340 receiver. The design is quintessential Harman/Kardon, which is to say, it looks fantastic. It is feature-rich, well priced, and most importantly, the audio performance is top-notch. I would definitely recommend trying this model out if you are in the market for a mid-level receiver.
 

Related Links...

Read More...

Thursday, May 1, 2008

Creek Audio Destiny integrated amplifier

Creek Audio Destiny integrated amplifier Creek Audio Destiny integrated amplifier Creek Audio Destiny integrated amplifier Creek Audio Destiny integrated amplifier Creek Audio Destiny integrated amplifier Creek Audio Destiny integrated amplifier Creek Audio Destiny integrated amplifier Creek Audio Destiny integrated amplifier Creek Audio Destiny integrated amplifier  HI-FI, Sterio, Home Theater, Audiophile, Amplifier, Speaker

The one thing I've liked about designer Mike Creek of Creek Audio as much as his design talent is his predictability. I've been following his integrated-amplifier designs for nearly 20 years now, having reviewed, in sequence, the CAS4140s2 (for another magazine), the 4240SE (Stereophile, December 1995, Vol.18 No.12), and the 5350SE (March 2001, Vol.24 No.3). In each case, I was sufficiently impressed with the review sample that I bought it and made it my new reference in my second, affordable system. The predictable part comes from Creek's traditional nomenclature: an "s2" or "SE" (Special Edition) designation has always denoted a modest upgrade, and a numerical uptick in the model number a more significant upgrade, the level of significance denoted by the specific digit being increased. Hence, the update from 4240 to 5350 is intended to indicate a greater improvement in sound than the update from 4140 to 4240.

But with his latest integrated amplifier, Creek has thrown his entire numerical upgrade system out the window. In his view, the Creek Destiny ($2200) is such a giant step up in design and sound from its predecessor, the $1495 5350SE, that it requires entirely new nomenclature. Still, he's keeping the 5350SE, now slightly redesigned and rechristened the Creek Classic, in production as well.

The Creek Destiny's external appearance indicates significant improvements in construction quality and cosmetics. The spartan, minimalist aesthetic of earlier Creek gear has been replaced by the sleek, the sexy, the modern, the rugged—the Destiny's 22-lb weight reminds me more of Krell gear than of Creek. In an e-mail, Mike Creek explained: "The Destiny amp is enormously strong and could probably withstand being driven over with a car, although nobody has tried this yet, due to the value of the parts involved." Moreover, the front-panel controls are logically laid out, and the elaborate remote control is designed to also control the companion Destiny CD player.

My comments here reflect the Destiny integrated's performance with my usual analog and digital front-ends, as well as with the new Destiny CD player (footnote 1). (Roy Hall, of Creek importer Music Hall, insisted on sending me a Destiny CDP as well.) I listened to the Destiny with a number of different loudspeakers, but most of my conclusions here were drawn in the context of Monitor Audio's RS6 Silver and Joseph Audio's RM7 XL Special Edition speakers (a review of the latter is underway).

The Design
For the Destiny, the discrete analog MOSFET circuitry Creek has used since 1993 was refined and upgraded with the introduction of separate power-supply and voltage-referencing circuits for each channel. The Destiny also includes Surface Mount Technology (SMT) to reduce the space taken up by the amplifier circuits and improve the layout. This, according to Creek, allows the signal path and amplification to be located on the top layer of the circuit board, and the power supplies and ground to be located on the bottom layer. The Destiny is also fully dual-mono, and its low-noise, 300VA toroidal transformer has separate windings for the preamp and power-amp circuits. In addition, the left and right channels have their own low-impedance DC power supplies, fed from two separate Shottky-barrier diode bridge rectifiers and multi-capacitor reservoirs, for a total of 20,000µF. Creek claims output power of more than 100Wpc into 8 ohms (both channels driven) and 200W into 4 ohms (one channel driven).

The Destiny's elaborate array of protection circuits is designed to monitor temperature, current, DC offsets, power-supply status, and overdrive situations. If any of these conditions exceeds preset conditions, a microprocessor takes action and either mutes the input signal, separates the speaker outputs, or, in extreme cases, shuts off the main power.

These protection circuits turned out to be a problem with my first sample of the Destiny, which shut down several times for seemingly no reason, the shutdown in each case preceded by a slight, phasey high-frequency distortion in one channel. I sent the amp back to Mike Creek, who couldn't replicate the problem but said that the sample was from an early production run and may have included some off-spec capacitors. The second sample he sent me, from a later production run, ran flawlessly. Aside from the minor hiccup with the first sample, the two Destinys sounded identical.

The Destiny has five line-level inputs, a tape-monitor loop, a headphone amplifier, and two sets of speaker outputs, which can be run concurrently or separately. The Destiny will eventually have optional plug-in boards for either a moving-magnet/moving-coil phono stage or an integrated DAC, but as these were not yet in production, I used the phono-stage plug-in from my 5350SE and an additional pair of interconnects. The Destiny's preamp and power-amp sections can be used separately, and, although the integrated has a passive preamp section, there's also the option of switching in an additional gain section in the line stage, which can add up to 9dB in increments of 3dB.

I have mixed views about the unorthodox speaker terminals on the rear panel. They're rugged and angled—it's literally impossible to short them out—but they're designed for bare wires or banana plugs. I'm used to spade lugs and five-way binding posts, so this disturbed me at first. And with the spade lugs fastened to the Speaker A terminals, the odd angle made it impossible to fit a second pair of banana plugs into the Speaker B terminals. That said, I found that the Destiny's posts grabbed the spade lugs on my speaker cables better than most five-way types do.



Footnote 1: Creek Audio's 24-bit/192kHz Destiny CD player ($2500) visually resembles the Destiny integrated amplifier and seems cut from the same sonic cloth. It shared with the Destiny integrated the same pristine, extended, and delicate high frequencies, along with portrayals of ambience, air, and subtle low-level dynamic articulation that more resembled a good vinyl front-end or analog master tape than anything digital. Unlike Creek's CD53 Mk.II, a sample of which I own, the Creek Destiny so clearly outperformed my California Audio Labs Icon Mk.II Power Boss that I was looking for some way to justify its purchase. The CAL made my decision easier: Toward the end of the reviewing process, after 15 years of loyal service as my reference CD player, the CAL gave up the ghost.—Robert J. Reina

The Sound
I can't comment on the timbral characteristics of the Creek Destiny because, across the entire frequency spectrum, I heard not a single deviation from neutrality—this is the least colored component I've ever reviewed. Here are its strengths:

• pristine, extended, and detailed high frequencies with no trace of hardness, and a purity and delicacy that reminded me more of the pricier Jeff Rowland Design Group products than of older Creek designs; appearing in my listening notes many times: "Clean! Clean! Clean!"

• an organic rendering of low-level dynamic articulation and subtleties that reminded me of expensive tubed gear, and a powerful sense of high-level dynamic slam that, with the right recordings, could be startling

• superb rendition of inner detail across the frequency spectrum, combined with abilities to render hall sound, image specificity, and ambience that rivaled much more expensive separates

It's that detail thing that most got me. Throughout my notes appear such comments as: "never heard that bongo part," "vocal phrasings I'd never noticed before," "guitar detail I'd never heard before"—all about recordings I'd heard dozens of times before. The Destiny is the kind of amplifier that made me want to put down my pen, kick back, and listen to music. Which I did—for many, many hours.

The Destiny's rich, silky, holographic presentation of Madeleine Peyroux's voice on her Dreamland CD (Atlantic 82936-2) was one thing, but I focused more on Marc Ribot's finger-picked dobro. Although very familiar with this disc, this was the first time I'd noticed that Ribot uses different dynamic attacks on his instrument's lead, rhythm, and bass strings. Similarly, listening to the a cappella "Our Prayer," from Brian Wilson's SMiLE (CD, Nonesuch 79846-2), I was easily able to follow the dynamic inflections of each separate vocal line.

Listening to Timothy Seelig and the Turtle Creek Chorale's recording of John Rutter's Requiem (HDCD, Reference RR57-CD) was a treat. Aside from the glorious and airy voice of soprano Nancy Keith and the extended upper register of the flute, I was amazed at how easy I could follow the low-level organ-pedal lines way down in the mix. They were deep, effortless, and uncolored. My notes: "with tears in my eyes, the naturalness, the drama, ahhhh!"

Twentieth-century chamber music let the Creek strut its stuff on difficult high-frequency passages. The shimmering extended partials of all the percussion instruments in George Crumb's Night Music (LP, Candide 31113) were breathtaking. Swedish composer Christer Lindvall's bombastic chamber work Earth Bow, from Rhizome (CD, Phono Suecia PSCD 154), features electric guitar and percussion—my speakers seemed to disappear, with all instruments placed precisely along the wide, deep soundstage.

The Destiny's ease with highly modulated passages of orchestral recordings made it easy for me to analyze each work's structure. Listening to David Chesky's Violin Concerto, from Area 31 (SACD/CD, Chesky SACD299, CD layer), it was very easy to hear the subtle pitch inflections on the timpani, violinist Tom Chiu's phrasing in his solo passages, and the low-level bassoon line under the hairier orchestral parts.

Jazz freaks will love the Destiny. On "I Heard It Through the Grapevine," from Bill Frisell's East/West (CD, Nonesuch 79863-2), the Creek's superb articulation of transients let me follow the subtle dynamic inflections of Kenny Wollenson's brushes as if I were attending a live performance. With Keith Jarrett's Radiance (CD, ECM 1960/61), I could follow the master's inflections and dynamics in excruciating detail—it was as if I could see his fingers on the keys. The upper ranges of the piano were shimmering and extended without a touch of brightness. The neo-romantic dynamic swells that are critical to this music shone through as they do when I see Jarrett live in performance. And the tandem crescendos of Don Fiorino's guitar and Mark Flynn's drums in "Crushing Heaves of Silence," from Attention Screen's La Tessitura (CD, Hojo HOJO110), were reproduced without strain or hint of compression.

The Creek's high-frequency purity came through in spades with Sonic Youth's "Becuz," from Washing Machine (CD, Geffen DGCD-24825). The upper registers of Thurston Moore and Lee Ranaldo's just-intonation Fender Jazzmasters shimmered with endless decay and pristine drama. The Destiny's abilities in high-level dynamic slam were particularly noteworthy with recordings that had dramatic and extended bass information. When I cranked up Kraftwerk's "Man Machine," from Minimum/Maximum (CD, EMI ASW 60611), to well past 100dB through both the Monitor and Joseph speakers, the lowest bass-synth blasts caused visible and tactile movement of my pants legs from across the room.

The Others
I was dying to compare the Destiny ($2395) to my own Creek 5350SE integrated ($1495). John Atkinson also sent along NAD's C 372 integrated ($899), which Jim Austin favorably reviewed in the October 2006 Stereophile.

Like the Destiny, the 5350SE is a neutral performer, although its midbass is very slightly warmer. To me, this implies that the Destiny may have set a new standard for midbass clarity in my system. Dynamics at both extremes were superior with the Destiny, whose highs were more detailed, delicate, and extended. The Destiny also revealed more inner midrange detail and had a greater sense of ease. Both amps were superb at articulating transients.

The NAD C 372 had a sweet, delicate midrange, but revealed less detail than the Destiny, and vocals were not as holographically presented. The NAD's highs were less extended and airy, while the Destiny revealed more hall sound and ambience. The NAD's midbass, too, was warmer and not as defined as the Destiny's, which also did better with high-level dynamics.

Conclusion
I've been a fan of Creek Audio for many years, but even I was surprised at how impressed I was with the Destiny—Mike Creek had already set his standard very high with the 5350SE. But I'm happy to make the Destiny my new reference in affordable integrated amplifiers, and have decided to buy Creek's superb Destiny CD player as well. In fact, I was intoxicated by the combination of the Destinys with the Monitor Audio Silver RS6 speakers. The trio produced a detailed, delicate, dynamic, uncolored sound that rivaled what systems costing twice as much can manage. I strongly suggest that dealers who sell both Creek and Monitor gear audition this system.

Mike Creek, you've done it again. Keep raising that bar!

Related Links...

Read More...

Cayin A-300B integrated amplifier

Cayin A-300B integrated amplifier Cayin A-300B integrated amplifier Cayin A-300B integrated amplifier Cayin A-300B integrated amplifier Cayin A-300B integrated amplifier Cayin A-300B integrated amplifier Cayin A-300B integrated amplifier Cayin A-300B integrated amplifier Cayin A-300B integrated amplifier Cayin A-300B integrated amplifier Cayin A-300B integrated amplifier  HI-FI, Sterio, Home Theater, Audiophile, Amplifier, Speaker

By now, even the shortest-sighted cynic has to admit that the single-ended-triode (SET) amplifier, which reappeared on the domestic audio scene over a decade ago, represents more than just a passing fad. And while no amp of such questionable relevance to the average loudspeaker will ever be considered the norm, so is it true that the SET's charms have earned it a permanent seat at the table. There will always be manufacturers who want to build SETs, just as there will always be people who want to perform Shakespeare or distill absinthe.

The genre has also had a lucky break: the SET revival was followed closely by the emergence of a new manufacturing power, one with both a flair for tube electronics and the geopolitical wherewithal to keep consumer prices low. That power, of course, is the People's Republic of China—from which I'm happy to see new single-ended products regularly emerge.

Consider the Cayin A-300B integrated amp, made by Spark (aka Zhuhai Spark) of Guangdon Province. Ten or more years ago, you might have been able to find a 300B integrated amp this well built, and you might have been able to find a 300B amp this affordable—but you certainly wouldn't have found both in the same package.

Description
The package in question is a lushly chromed chassis with a terraced aluminum alloy faceplate, sculpted housings for the mains and output transformers, and a thickly enameled protective cage that fits so beautifully, you'd think someone actually cares whether or not you like it. An alloy remote control is also a part of the scenery.

Inside the A-300B is a mix of circuit boards and point-to-point wiring, each doing the job it ought to be doing. Remote-control circuitry, a phalanx of relays for input selection, and other bits and pieces account for the circuit board, while the wiring is well represented—and remarkably well executed—throughout most of the audio and power-supply circuitry. The wiring is neat, the soldering is saintly, and the parts are nice enough, with a sprinkling of such names as Multicap, Nichicon, and Alps. Inside my review sample were no rough metal edges, no questionable solder joints, and not so much as a speck of dust.

The A-300B's power supply holds no surprises, although I am impressed that, forward of the AC transformer (a toroid), it's an entirely dual-mono design. I'm also struck by the size and quality of the electrolytic capacitors chosen to smooth the AC: They share a pi filter of the usual sort with a hefty, frame-style choke. Each channel has its own 5AR4 tube for B+ rectification, while lower voltages (for tube filaments and logic circuits—a lovely if odd juxtaposition) are uncurled with solid-state rectifier blocks.

The Cayin's amplification design is similarly straightforward: The high-level input signal is directed to a 100k ohm volume potentiometer, from whence it's capacitively coupled to the grid of a 6SL7 dual-triode cascade, for pure voltage gain. The final plate of that tube drives the grid of a 6SN7 dual triode, configured as a cathode follower for low impedance. The full waveform then goes to the grid of a 300B output triode—biased, of course, for pure class-A operation.

The output tubes are run in fixed-bias mode, and each channel has its own easily accessed bias trim pot (a decent-quality digital voltmeter is required). My review sample of the A-300B arrived perfectly well adjusted for the Chinese output tubes supplied, and has required little in the way of further attention. (The Cayin's packing materials are good enough that the amp can be shipped with every tube in place.) There's also a heater-balance pot for each output tube, so the user can adjust the outputs for minimal hum as the tubes age. Filament voltage for each directly heated 300B is rectified, and appears to be just a shade over 5V. On the anode side of the tube I found a rail voltage of about 388V DC—neither the highest nor the lowest one sees in contemporary 300B amps.

The Cayin's circuitry may be straightforward; its transformers are anything but. According to the importer, VAS Industries, Inc., the primary and secondary windings of the frame-style output trannies are coated and sealed in vacuum chambers prior to being potted in the more traditional sense. That's done in the interest of preventing vibrations and enhancing consistency, longevity, and noiselessness.

Indeed, the Cayin A-300B was among the quietest single-ended amps I've used, in every way. I couldn't hear a bit of mechanical sound from the vicinity of the amplifier itself, and only the faintest 60Hz hum through my very efficient Lowther PM2A drivers/Medallion horns. Used with the somewhat less sensitive (92dB, as measured by John Atkinson) but still very efficient Audio Note AN-E Lexus Signature speakers, the Cayin was virtually silent at idle.

The A-300B's user controls are minimal. There's a large volume control at the center of the front panel, and to its right a small button for toggling through the various input selections (including the selection for an outboard preamplifier). One more button allows the user to toggle between zero and minimal feedback; I preferred and relied exclusively on the former. The remote handset duplicates all of those controls and adds one more: a mute toggle. Sadly, the A-300B has neither a balance knob nor a mono switch.

Setup and listening
I tried the Cayin A-300B in a variety of settings, but always as an integrated amplifier. (One can use it as only a power amp by driving a dedicated pair of input jacks with a separate preamp.) In my living room (19' by 27'), the A-300B drove the aforementioned Audio Note and Lowther loudspeakers. In my much smaller (12' by 18') listening room, it drove the Lowthers and a supplemental choice of speaker (see below). At no time did I hear the sort of clipping that might have suggested I'd pushed the A-300B too far.

Despite its pristine condition, I had the sense that my sample of the Cayin had been run-in ahead of time—either that, or the A-300B just isn't one of those products whose sound changes appreciably during the first few days or weeks of use. In any event, I was impressed from the start by the A-300B's very wide bandwidth—for a SET amp. My first 300B experience was 10 years ago, with the Cary Audio Design 300 SEI ($4500), a sweet-sounding product that was also very good-looking and pleasant to use. The Cayin's top-end extension, in particular, went beyond the Cary's, with open-sounding trebles and a clean, nongritty way with such sounds as cymbal decays and the very highest notes in the piano's right hand.

But the Cayin's greatest strength may be its sheer musicality—which, again, means nothing more or less than the ability to reproduce sound in a manner that's consonant with music, as an event in time carried by distinct pitches and rhythms. The Cayin was as pitch-certain an amp as I've ever heard: I could listen to it for literally hours on end without the sort of fatigue brought on by electronics that fail in that regard—and, in fact, complex lines seemed musically clearer than usual. Violinist Marianne Rônez's cadenza in the Prelude of Biber's first Mystery Sonata (CD, Winter & Winter 910 029-2) was fiercely clear and easy to follow. Similarly, the crazy polyrhythms, bass-guitar chording, and soprano-sax improvisations in Captain Beefheart's "Japan in a Dishpan," from Lick My Decals Off, Baby (CD, Enigma Retro 7 73394-2), were clearly crazy.

On a related matter, the Cayin A-300B's ability to uncover softly played lines and to present them with as little musical ambiguity as possible was quite good. The fairly recent recording of Mahler's early cantata, Das klagende Lied, by Michael Tilson Thomas and noted soloists (CD, BMG 68599-2), showed off the Cayin's ability to pull melodies from the mess, seemingly at the listener's will. My listening notes also point to the George Szell recording of Strauss's Don Juan (SACD, Sony SS 89037). Admittedly, the Strauss disc already has a lot going for it in that regard, thanks to a combination of good sound and Szell's unusually clear musical direction; still, the Cayin framed and enhanced those qualities, making it easy for me to understand what the cellos or violas were doing at any given moment.

The Cayin's way with sonic details was just a bit off by comparison—and not quite as good as a typical 2A3-based SET. Although the A-300B brought a fine sense of clarity to Mieczyslaw Horszowski's slurry performance of Chopin's Waltz No.7 in C-sharp Minor, Op.64 No.2 (CD, BBC BBCL 4122-2), without making it sound overly mechanical in the manner of other, lesser amps, it was less successful than my Fi 2A3 Stereo at capturing the pianist's many instances of singing or humming along with the music. It was also less explicit with the intakes of breath heard throughout Nick Drake's "Way to Blue," from Five Leaves Left (CD, Island 422 842915-2, footnote 1), or the sounds of the many splices in the well-known Donald Johanos recording of Copland's Fanfare for the Common Man (LP, Vox Turnabout TV 34169).

But you could be forgiven for forgetting all that, in light of the Cayin's embodiment of that greatest of all SET strengths: the manner in which it let solo voices and solo instruments pull themselves out of the mix to appear before me with a presence unequaled by other amp technology. On the Nick Drake track, Drake's voice was utterly there. On the Rachmaninoff Symphonic Dances, from another great Johanos LP (LP, Vox Turnabout TV 341 45S), the saxophone was all but in the room, and had all of the spatial realism and texture I could have hoped for.

Remarkably—or not, I suppose—the Cayin was able to drive my Quad ESLs from its 16 ohm taps. Not only that, but at sensible volumes, the combination could even rock. I put on R.E.M.'s Reckoning (LP, IRS SP70044) without expecting much—and was utterly amazed by the decent sense of momentum and lack of egregious puffiness or slowing. Sure, the electric-bass notes billowed a bit more than they should have. But their attack components lined up well enough that rhythm and pacing didn't suffer at all.

The Cayin rocked out even more with my Lowther Medallion horns, of course, where a lack of bass extension was made up for by even more of a sense of momentum—and a great deal more impact on percussive sounds. The amp fairly tore through R.E.M.'s "Pretty Persuasion," also from Reckoning. For that matter, on every cut, Bill Berry's snare drum jumped realistically out of the mix, along with various other percussion instruments (the anvil-like sound in "Time After Time" being another example). The A-300B's lowest registers also sounded tighter and more controlled than I'm used to hearing from a 300B; SET aficionados will understand when I suggest that this is one of the few 300B amps I've heard that has 2A3 bass!

As with virtually all pairings of SETs and sympathetic loudspeakers that I've heard, orchestral music had fine scale and drama: Dynamic shadings were realistic, and peaks in the music startled me more than once. Through the Audio Note speakers in my living room, Furtwängler's astonishingly dynamic (mono) recording from 1951 of Beethoven's Symphony 9 (EMI 5 66953 2) was mesmerizing. I confess that I tried doing something else—paying bills—while listening to that with the Cayin amp one afternoon. I failed.

I hesitate to single out the Cayin A-300B for a description of its colorations, if only because they were the sort that seem endemic to 300B amplifiers. In particular, its sound was a little thicker than ideal in the upper bass and lower mids (not unlike a certain Scottish turntable I know and love). Tim O'Brien's voice is one that I know well, and on such albums as his own Two Journeys (CD, Howdy Skies HS-1004) and guitarist Slavek Hanzlik's Fall of My Dreams (CD, Sierra HS 67011-2), that voice was just a shade chestier—or diaphragmier—than real.

With my own Western Electric 300Bs in place of the stock Chinese output tubes, the Cayin lost some of that upper-bass plumminess—and gained both clarity and, especially, precision of stereo imaging. All the players in the breakneck "John Hardy" on Tony Rice's Cold on the Shoulder (CD, Rounder CD 0183) were more definite in their positions on the imaginary stage.

All in all, fine performance: more refined and more extended than the typical 300B SET, with all of the presence, drama, and textural richness the genre has to offer. A really nice amp.

Conclusions
If you happen to hear a great piece of music for the first time on a cloudy day, your point of view on that piece will forever be set a certain way. You can try all you want to explain your point of view—but how can you explain a cloudy day?

That's more or less how I feel about single-ended-triode amps: They make me listen to music a bit differently. How could I possibly describe such a thing?

I can try—certainly have tried—for a number of years. But there comes a point when the reader simply must have the experience for himself. Here's an opportunity. And it's one that I would never have expected even a few years ago.

The Cayin A-300B is a lovely product: intelligently designed, reassuringly well made, and achingly musical. If a domestic amplifier that sells for $3195 can be said to be a bargain, this is it—and while it's possible to get a little more by spending a lot more, it isn't possible to embarrass the A-300B in any way, to any extent. You could live with this forever.



Footnote 1: A fine-sounding digital reissue—and the rare "Red Book" CD that is not, in my opinion, improved on at all by DSD remastering (cf the compilation Nick Drake: A Treasury, Island B0003518-36).

Related Links...

Read More...

Bryston B100-DA SST DAC/integrated amplifier

Bryston B100-DA SST DAC/integrated amplifier Bryston B100-DA SST DAC/integrated amplifier Bryston B100-DA SST DAC/integrated amplifier Bryston B100-DA SST DAC/integrated amplifier Bryston B100-DA SST DAC/integrated amplifier Bryston B100-DA SST DAC/integrated amplifier Bryston B100-DA SST DAC/integrated amplifier Bryston B100-DA SST DAC/integrated amplifier Bryston B100-DA SST DAC/integrated amplifier  Bryston B100-DA SST DAC/integrated amplifier HI-FI, Sterio, Home Theater, Audiophile, Amplifier, Speaker

Over the years, I have used and enjoyed in my audio system large, single-purpose components. Each of these chassis has had but one role: preamplifier, amplifier, digital-to-audio converter (DAC), etc. I guess I've been just a little suspicious of products with multiple functions crammed into a single small chassis; I've figured that the designer may have cut a corner that could affect the sound.

Which brings me to the topic of this review, the Bryston B100-DA SST, which is three separate components in one slim chassis: a DAC, a preamplifier, and a 100Wpc power amplifier. (An MM phono module is also available.) Has serving all of these different functions compromised its sound?

There was another reason I was curious about the B100-DA SST. Its optional DAC made it very easy to use with a new type of audio component: the networked music player. Such devices—Slim Devices' Squeezebox and Roku's Soundbridge 1000, for examples—can stream digital music from the excellent Internet radio stations praised by Sam Tellig and Wes Phillips, or to a centralized digital music library, as extolled by John Atkinson. The B100-DA SST also avoids the need to use the often mediocre DACs found in some network players, and eliminates from the analog signal path the extra jacks, plugs, and connectors required when using an external DAC.

Internal components
The power-amplifier section of the B100-DA SST ($4395 as reviewed; I didn't specify the phono option) is based on the 2B-SST, Bryston's 100W basic two-channel power amp. It offers dual-mono architecture with two 250VA toroidal transformers; a third, smaller toroidal helps power the B100-DA's digital module. The amp contains over a dozen regulated or stabilized voltage supplies.

Removing the B100-DA's top panel revealed excellent build quality: minimal point-to-point wiring, high-quality resistors and capacitors, and thick, double-sided, glass-epoxy printed-circuit boards with clear markings. The B100-DA's analog preamplifier uses multiple-pole relays to switch sources, and an integrated resistance network is used to control the unit's volume. All analog signal circuits are fully discrete and Bryston uses 0.1% metal-film resistors, polystyrene capacitors, and selects and matches transistors by hand to keep noise and distortion to absolute minimums.

The B100-DA's DAC is described in an article written by one of the company's customers, Jeff Switzer, that appeared in Vol.8 No.3 of the company's online newsletter . A digital signal input through the S/PDIF jacks on the B100-DA's rear panel is fed via impedance-matching transformers to a Cirrus Logic C58420 digital interface chip. This reduces jitter and upsamples the data from 16-bit/44.1kHz to 24/96. As Switzer states, "the upsampling process doesn't add any new data to that which came off the CD but it puts the data in a form which can better be used by the DAC." Another advantage is that a "new clock signal is applied which causes a significant reduction in jitter."

The D/A conversion is handled by a Crystal CS43122 chip. A digital low-pass filter is applied to the signal before its conversion to analog, and an analog filter afterward. The DAC's performance is tightly regulated by a separate filtered analog power supply with carefully routed grounds. The same circuitry can be found in Bryston's SP 2, the five-channel preamplifier and digital processor reviewed by Kalman Rubinson in his "Music in the Round" column in September 2006 (Vol.29 No.9). The only difference is that the B100-DA's DAC reclocks and resamples the digital input.

The B100-DA is built to last. Each unit must survive a 100-hour factory burn-in in which a squarewave input signal drives the amplifier into a load capacitor at slightly under clipping for one hour, followed by one hour off, and so on. This load is designed to draw the amplifier's maximum current delivery on the squarewave's rising leg. Unlike a resistive load, which dissipates all the energy as heat, the capacitor feeds back the entire signal into the amplifier, which puts maximal stress on the output stages. This heats the amplifier, cools it, and heats it again. This expansion and contraction exposes any loose connections or devices subject to early failure. After burn-in, each B100-DA is bench-tested, and those results are shipped with the unit.

Such overengineering, extensive burn-in, and building to the stringent, constant-use demands of professionals allow Bryston to offer its unique warranty program: Bryston will pay parts and labor costs, plus shipping one way, for the first 20 years of ownership (except for the digital circuits, which are warranted for five years, parts and labor).

Rear-panel connections, front-panel controls
At each end of the B100-DA's rear panel are pairs of speaker terminals. Between them are 10 unbalanced analog RCA input jacks per channel, configured in two rows of five each for each side. There is also rear-panel access to the drive circuits for outboard infrared LEDs, and a bidirectional RS-232 data connector for downloading from Bryston's website. Below this is a 12V remote trigger output, and next to it an IEC 320 AC power inlet. A single Connected/Separate switch next to each channel's input bank lets the user internally connect or disconnect the preamp to/from the power-amp section.

Digital streaming music up to 24/96 can be fed to the B100-DA's S/PDIF coaxial inputs or TosLink optical inputs, which are found near the center of the rear panel. The innermost bottom RCA jacks are designated D1 (S/PDIF coax 2 among the left-channel sockets) and D2 (S/PDIF coax 2 among the right). In the middle of the rear panel are two TosLink optical input jacks, designated D3 and D4.

On the B100-DA's front panel one finds, on the left, a row of seven pushbuttons, above each an LED. These 7 buttons are labeled along the bottom, from left to right: Aux 2, Aux 1/Phono, CD, Tuner, TV, Video, Rec. Pressing the leftmost pushbutton, Aux 2, activates the B100-DA/s internal DAC, causing its LED to turn green. When the LEDs of D1 (S/PDIF 1 source), D2 (S/PDIF source), D3 (TosLink 1 source), or D4 (TosLink 2 also glow green, this indicates that a PCM digital bitstream is present. If no bitstream is available, or if the bitstream is incorrect (ie, not PCM), the LED will turn red. Pushing Aux 2 again toggles its light off and puts the B100-DA in analog mode. This means that only one source LED of the remaining six input-selector buttons will be illuminated, indicating the exact analog source. The large, anodized, motorized master volume knob can be operated via the remote control in both analog and digital modes. Also on the front panel are the headphone jack, IR sensor, and pushbuttons for Balance, Mute, Clip, and Power.

Bryston offers the B100-DA's remote control as a $400 option. Although I grumbled at the thought of having to pay for a remote, I changed my tune when I held this full-function example in my hand: it's very well made, its brushed aluminum is highly attractive, and it controls everything: selection of any source, volume up/down, mute, balance, power off/on, and discrete code entry. Its backlighting is even triggered by a motion detector—it lights up as soon as you pick it up. This is the most attractive and cleverly designed remote control I've seen for a high-end audio product. If you buy a B100-DA, definitely get the remote as well.

Music Serving
As I said, I chose to review the DAC-equipped B100 so I could use it with my network music player. I use a Slim Devices Squeezebox network player ($299) placed atop my Krell KRC-28 CD player, connected via a WiFi link to the D-Link DW 624 router sitting in the kitchen, about 20' away. The music is stored on a IBM X-30 laptop, which sits one floor below in my office, which is also connected wirelessly to my WiFi network. (I use a DWL G800 AP D-Link signal booster.) I connected the Squeezebox's S/PDIF output to the B100-DA's D1 S/PDIF input, using a 1.5m length of Wireworld Starlight digital coaxial cable.

I then installed the Slimserver software on my laptop and used Windows Media Player v.10 to rip tracks from my favorite music CDs as Windows Media Audio (WMA) Lossless files— ie, the best sound quality, which requires 206–411MB of hard-drive space per CD. The Slimserver software (v.6.5.0, downloaded from Slim Devices' website) allowed me to gather these lossless music files into a playlist I titled "Stereophile Music CD Test Program." For the listening tests, I also downloaded Beethoven's Symphony 9, with Wyn Morris conducting the London Symphony, from the iTunes website (footnote 1).

Returning upstairs, I remotely browsed my laptop's music folders via the Squeezebox until I found the My Music directory and the "Stereophile Music CD Test Program" playlist. During my audition of the B100-DA, I selected various tracks from this playlist from my listening-room chair, using the Squeezebox's handheld remote. I also used the free subscription to Pandora.com supplied with the Squeezebox to set up my own Internet radio station to play Keith Jarrett recordings over my system.

Setup
The B100-DA SST's chassis is slim, and smaller than that of the Bryston 4B-SST power amplifier, with which I compared it. My components are mounted on a long sidewall, the amplifiers situated out in the room behind my Quad ESL-989 electrostatic loudspeakers. I had to think about just where I would place the B100-DA: with the source equipment on the shelves, or with the amplifiers? The former required very long runs of speaker cable from the sidewall shelves to the speakers, the latter long runs of interconnect from the SACD player, CD player, and tuner—or a Manley Skipjack source switcher. I decided to put the B100-DA and Squeezebox on my equipment shelf and run long speaker cables to the Quads.

Despite the B100-DA's relatively small chassis, its speaker terminals are still large enough to make speaker-cable connections tight and fast. As on other Bryston products, the B100-DA's hollow posts can directly accept single banana plugs, even though they're also placed the requisite 19–25mm apart to meet EU regulations. The posts are also shrouded in plastic to keep fingers from directly contacting the metal. Slots in the shrouds accommodate spade lugs up to 5/16" thick.

Listening
After burning in the B100-DA SST by having it drive my Quad ESL-989s, I began feeding its DAC digital signals from my Krell KRC-28 CD player and the Slim Devices Squeezebox, which let me compare CD and wireless sources. Listening to "Too Rich for My Blood," from Patricia Barber's Café Blue (CD, Premonition/Blue Note 5 21810 2), I could detect no difference between the digital outputs of the Krell playing the CD and the Squeezebox playing the losslessly compressed file of the same track through the B100-DA's internal DAC—but both digital sources were decidedly better than the SB's internal DAC feeding an analog signal to the B100-DA. For the bulk of my listening, I listened only to streaming digital files fed to the B100-DA.

Through its own internal DAC, the B100-DA's bass response reminded me strongly of the Bryston 3B-ST's. I enjoyed the solidity of the sustained pedal chords from the Lay Family Concert Organ in John Rutter's "The Lord Is My Light and My Salvation" (CD, Reference RR-57CD), and the staccato plucked bass and deep synthesizer in "Something's Wrong," from Randy Edelman's score for the film My Cousin Vinny (CD, Varèse Sarabande VSD-5364). The synthesizer notes in Terry Dorsey's "Ascent," from Time Warp (CD, Telarc CD-80106), were well defined and went deep, and I could easily discern pitch changes in low-frequency synthesizer notes on "Behind the Veil," from Jeff Beck's Beck's Guitar Shop (CD, Epic EK 44313).

Besides reproducing deep bass, the B100-DA could create a sense of depth and space that seemed an accurate facsimile/re-creation of the recording venue. This was evident when I listened to Jean Guillou's transcription for pipe organ of Mussorgsky's Pictures at an Exhibition (Dorian DOR-90117)—in Gnomus, the organ was reproduced with the airiness I associate with a cathedral. The B100-DA could also create more intimate ambiences, such as the one heard surrounding Glen Moore's plucked string bass in "The Silence of a Candle," from Oregon's Beyond Words (CD, Chesky JD130).

Playing the digital stream, the B100-DA's highly satisfying performance captured the different timpani pitches in Stravinsky's The Rite of Spring, as performed by Eiji Oue conducting the Minnesota Orchestra (CD, Reference RR-70CD, tracks 21–24). The B100-DA tracked the pitch and dynamic contrasts heard on this excellent recording, coaxing surprisingly deep bass from the Quads. The Bryston's midrange reproduction was most impressive—the brassiness of trumpets, for example, was raw and involving without being annoying.

The B100-DA revealed the richness of Patricia Monheit's dark voice in her rendition of the 1941 torch song "Besame Mucho," from The Frank and Joe Show's 331/3 (Hyena SD 9320). This track was just as enthralling for its "seductive timbral voluptuousness," as John Marks described it in "The Fifth Element" in the April 2006 issue. The B100-DA also conveyed the beguiling sadness and sweetness of Richard and Linda Thompson harmonizing on "Dimming of the Day," from the soundtrack of Divine Secrets of the Ya-Ya Sisterhood (CD, DMZ/Columbia CK 86534). Paul Simon's voice remained clear and warm at high volumes as he sang "Trailways Bus," from Songs from The Capeman (CD, Warner Bros. 46814-2).

The B100-DA's highs were clean, open, effortless, grain-free, and extended. Paul Simon's vocal sibilants at the beginning of "Trailways Bus" didn't hiss, but were natural, not irritating. Billy Drummond's brushed ride cymbal in "The Mooche," from the Jerome Harris Quintet's Rendezvous (CD, Stereophile STPH013-2), had the characteristic buzz and shimmer of wire brushes, not the static-like hiss heard from lesser amplifiers.

The B100-DA's imaging was delightful. Patricia Barber's voice was holographic and riveting on "Too Rich for my Blood," the instruments behind her clearly separated and occupying their own spaces. In Ariel Ramirez's Misa Criolla (CD, Philips 420 955-2), tenor José Carreras was centered, surrounded by huge amounts of space that helped conjure up an empty, desolate ambience of solitude and desolation. Live recordings also benefited, as revealed by the intimacy and relaxed atmosphere of the Green Mill nightclub, where Patricia Barber recorded Companion (CD, Premonition/Blue Note 5 22963 2). The width of the Bryston's soundstaging was also impressive, as I heard when I played the instrumental finish of Richard Thompson's "Why Must I Plead," from Rumor and Sigh (CD, Capitol CDP 7 95713 2). The B100-DA was able to move the guitar's image well beyond the outer edge of my right-channel Quad ESL-989.

The dynamic range was very good to excellent. In "The Hand-Off," from James Horner's soundtrack score for Sneakers (CD, Columbia CK 53146), the piano scales exploded out of dead-black silence. And while not as dynamic-sounding as the Revel Salon speakers, my Quads when driven by the B100-DA captured the explosive rim shots, tom-tom beats, kick-drum notes, and audience callouts during the drum solo in "The Maker," from Emmylou Harris' Spyboy (CD, Eminent EM-25001-2).

Conclusions
I'm excited about Bryston's B100-DA SST integrated amplifier. Not only is it a rugged and reliable amplifier with a 20-year warranty, it's small, compact, and with the DAC option, it will integrate well with an audio system based on a centralized, wirelessly delivered music library. Whether playing music from a hard drive, or downloaded, or streamed from such services as Pandora.com or Rhapsody.com, the owner of a B100-DA will be able to tap an excellent sonic source.

Sonically, the B100-DA has much of the 4B-SST's character, with its bass definition and speed, openness of high frequencies, and soundstage width, lacking only the 4B-SST's deep-bass punch and greater macrodynamics.While it's easier to warm up to an amplifier with a seductively captivating midrange, such as the much more expensive VTL S-400 ($20,000/pair), the B100-DA is much more neutral and can also throw one of the deepest, broadest soundstages of any amplifier I've heard.

And for streaming digital sources, I'll take the B100-DA's tonal neutrality, conveniences, small size, easy installation, built-in DAC, and backlit remote. Combine all of those features with the B100-DA's bass definition, wide soundstaging, and open highs, and I can hear the music's subtlest details through my Quad ESL-989s. Like Bryston's own 14B-SST and 4B-SST, their little B100-DA SST integrated amplifier connects me to what I truly love in my music collection, and proves that multiple audio functions can work well in a small package.



Footnote 1: According to John Atkinson, though downloaded iTunes music files are protected by Apple's DRM software, the DRM is eliminated when the owner burns the files to a CD. I got the four MP4P music files (one for each movement) comprising Beethoven's Symphony 9 to play over a Slim Devices Squeezebox by first burning them to a blank CD, then ripping them back to my computer's hard drive.

Related Links...

Read More...

Simaudio Moon Evolution i-7 integrated amplifier

Simaudio Moon Evolution i-7 integrated amplifier Simaudio Moon Evolution i-7 integrated amplifier Simaudio Moon Evolution i-7 integrated amplifier Simaudio Moon Evolution i-7 integrated amplifier Simaudio Moon Evolution i-7 integrated amplifier Simaudio Moon Evolution i-7 integrated amplifier Simaudio Moon Evolution i-7 integrated amplifier Simaudio Moon Evolution i-7 integrated amplifier Simaudio Moon Evolution i-7 integrated amplifier Simaudio Moon Evolution i-7 integrated amplifier HI-FI, Sterio, Home Theater, Audiophile, Amplifier, Speaker

I was the member of the family on whom the others could depend for technical assistance: mending eyeglass frames, fixing the radio, replacing the lightbulb in the oven, getting the car to idle smoothly. No job too big or too small. House calls a specialty.

That began to change when the world became more dependent on consumer electronics—except for perfectionist audio, of course—and as consumer electronics became more and more dependent on microprocessors. "How do I reset the time on my VCR?" I don't know. "How do I turn off the flash on my camera?" I don't know. "Where are all the songs I downloaded last night?" I don't know.

Slowly but surely, it dawned on my family that I'm an idiot, for the simple reason that I no longer seem to know very much. I chafed at that conclusion, for the simple reason that I shouldn't be expected to know what I can't be expected to know—at least until I've had a chance to read the instructions.

I retreated to my little world of belt-driven record players and loudspeakers stuffed with jute: things I know about. But the world came knocking again, anxious to show what a fraud I really am. There it was, in black and white, on p.8 of the owner's manual that arrived with the Simaudio Moon Evolution i-7 ($6000), which has replaced the Moon i-5 as the Canadian manufacturer's top integrated amplifier: "The Moon i-7 integrated amplifier includes powerful software..."

Uh-oh.

"What follows are step-by-step examples of how to configure an input..."

I felt like a small, frightened woodland animal. But my fears proved ill-founded: The instructions were clear and easy to follow. Within 15 minutes, I'd given every one of the inputs a custom label, some of which were childishly amusing.

It wasn't hard at all. So I carried on...

Description
The Moon Evolution i-7 is one of Simaudio's statement products: a good-looking, surprisingly heavy (58 lbs), solid-state integrated amplifier built into an aluminum alloy chassis more or less equal in size to that of the SuperNova CD player, which Wes Phillips wrote about in the January 2007 Stereophile. The i-7 comes with a nice-looking remote handset, built into a molar-shaped alloy enclosure so heavy that, when I accidentally dropped it, it dented the floor. Seriously.

The i-7 is fully balanced, although the single-ended inputs outnumber their balanced counterpart four to one. There's also a tape loop, a pair of auxiliary line-level outputs (their output impedance is a low 50 ohms), special jacks for communicating with other Simaudio products, and a nine-pin RS-232 port: something else I don't know much about.

The front side of the Moon is a marvel of beauty and usefulness. Scattered around a red-lit display are the soft-touch buttons needed to run the amplifier's various setup routines, as well as switches for the monitor loop, mute, standby mode, display lighting, and two buttons for toggling back and forth among the five line-level inputs.

A large knob off to the right actuates an optical encoder, which itself selects among many combinations of metal-film resistors for signal attenuation. (The knob is also used as a selector switch during the setup routine.) This is Simaudio's M-eVol, a resistive-array circuit with 130 discrete steps, intended to avoid the distortions associated with old-fashioned potentiometers. The M-eVol system is also speed-sensitive, which is something no potentiometer can match: In the lowest portion of its overall range, from 0dB to 30dB, loudness is adjusted in 1dB steps; above that, the speed with which the knob is turned determines whether loudness is to be adjusted in steps of 0.5dB (slow turning) or 1dB (quick turning). Incidentally, the mute control works not by clamping input signal to ground, but by instantly switching the M-eVol system to zero—from whence it can, of course, be switched immediately back to the previous setting.

The Moon i-7 lacks a mono-blend or channel-reversal switch. Side-to-side balance is adjustable, but only from the remote—which makes more sense than doing it while standing next to the amp itself, I suppose. In any event, the user can adjust the left-to-right loudness differential in accordance with a hundred small steps; that was certainly enough for me.

To look inside the Moon's well-made chassis was to conclude that the i-7 is in fact a monumentally well-designed, high-tech power supply, with a nice integrated amp along for the ride. From the two wildly overspecified toroidal transformers forward, every bit of the power supply is discretely dual-mono. (Actually, the power supply for the logic circuitry isn't dual-mono, but then, I've always suspected that logic comes only in mono.) Everything looked stiff but sensible, and my search for a flaw in the layout—some weakness that might leave the power supply open to hum, or create ground points of differing potential—was as fruitless as playing chess with a master: Someone else had already thought of everything.

The audio circuitry is also dual-mono, built with a combination of discrete transistors and integrated circuits. The i-7 is a fully balanced differential design from input to output, and, in the interest of banishing timing distortions, does not use global feedback—a philosophy that Simaudio refers to as their Lynx technology. The i-7's preamp section operates in class-A, and the power amp operates in class-A up to 5Wpc, beyond which it works in class-AB.

Installation
Getting the Moon up and running was as straightforward as one could expect from an amp that weighs more than a nine-year-old girl. The user can, of course, simply plug the thing in straight out of the box, ignore the software setup routine, and play music—in which case the inputs remain unlabeled (apart from "B1," "S1," and so forth), and likewise remain unadjusted for volume "offset," which can be done later—with ease—to compensate for differences among various source components.

But straight out of the box, the i-7 didn't sound its best. During my first several days of listening, the Moon underwent the most noticeable changes I've ever heard from a solid-state amplifier—all of them for the better.

The Moon i-7 is shipped with a nondescript AC power cable, which I relied on for most of my listening. (I noted a small sonic improvement when I tried aftermarket cords from Cardas and JPS.) Spiked feet are also included, and those absolutely must be threaded into place—not so much for any sonic improvement (I heard none), but because the heavy amp has no feet at all without them, and the various edges, corners, and bolt heads on the bottom of its chassis can scratch finished surfaces. Simaudio supplies dimpled pucks for use with the spikes, thus eliminating at least one cosmetic concern.

Listening
After running in the Moon Evolution i-7 for a number of weeks, I sat down to some serious listening and was impressed from the start by the amp's clarity and apparent lack of coloration. Another four weeks later, I still can't detect much in the way of an obvious i-7 character. That in itself will be recommendation enough for some.

The i-7 had the requisite neutrality to allow the strings and woodwinds of Trevor Pinnock's English Concert to sound timbrally convincing in the group's live recording of Handel's Tamerlano, from 2002 (CD, Avie AV0001), and was sufficiently clean and transparent to preserve the spatial distinctions between soloists and continuo. Nearer the other end of the opera timeline, the Simaudio amp did a fine job with the famous Rudolf Kempe recording of Wagner's Lohengrin: It sailed through the many dramatic peaks ("Heil dir, O Tugendreiche!") without making the louder voices sound strained, and the Moon reproduced the sound of a modern orchestra with what I felt was just the right amount of bass weight—and not a shade more than was called for. Timpani, in particular, had fine heft, even when played subtly. I heard nothing in the way of added crispness or brightness, although I wouldn't have wanted the cymbals to sound any drier than they did.

The i-7 also used its clarity and cleanness to good effect on rock recordings. It uncovered layers of detail in the somewhat dense and overly reverberant soundfield of the Byrds' Sweetheart of the Rodeo (CD, Columbia CK 65150), in addition to which it was a great amp for helping to decipher otherwise murky lyrics. More important, the Moon i-7 was sufficiently free from those distortions that keep lesser amps from even suggesting the musical qualities of rhythm, pacing, and momentum. With the Simaudio amp at its heart, my system leaned into Roger McGuinn's opening bars on the Byrds' "Lover of the Bayou," from Untitled (CD, Mobile Fidelity UDCD 722). Swingier numbers—such as Django Reinhardt's crazy "Mystery Pacific," from a reissue of The Art of Django (CD, Beat Goes On BGOCD198), and Thelonious Monk's "Off Minor," from Monk's Music (LP, Riverside RLP-242)— never failed to involve me on a physical level.

One of the most obvious sonic distinctions between the Moon i-7 and the generally low-powered tube amplifiers I usually enjoy was a difference in spatial perspective. Listening to the Moon i-7, I found the "stage" significantly wider than I'm used to hearing—singers and players now stretched all the way from left of the left speaker to right of the right. At first I also thought that the Moon i-7 was lacking in spatial depth, but that proved untrue: That was merely what I expected to hear when first struck by the increase in stage width.

The localization of players and singers, as well as the sense of wholeness and solidity of instrumental and vocal images, was very good with the Moon i-7. On my favorite contemporary bluegrass recordings, such as Blue Highway's Midnight Storm (CD, Rebel REB-CD-1746) and Del McCoury's wonderful Del and the Boys (CD, Ceili CEIL2006), the sounds of the instruments were neatly lined up, each occupying a definite chunk of sonic air: a technological illusion, I know, and one that has very little to do with the way things really sound in concert—but it's there on the records, it's fun to hear, and the i-7 did a fine job of bringing it to life, neither dulling nor exaggerating the pleasant effect.

Generally speaking, a powerful amplifier can confer an indescribable sense of confidence on some listening experiences, especially of good piano recordings—and the Moon i-7 did not disappoint. I enjoyed using it to play the very rich and lyrical Bach Prelude BWV 659 (arranged by Busoni), "Nun Komm' der Heiden Heiland," recorded in the 1970s by Chris Copping lookalike Mindru Katz (CD, Cembal d'amour CD112); and my perennial favorite, pianist Jorge Bolet's Rediscovered Liszt Recital (CD, RCA 63748-2), including his frenzied performance of the overture to Wagner's Tannhäuser (which I enjoy, although some friends think Liszt's arrangement is grotesque). In the latter example, my playback system was unperturbed by even the loudest chords, although the sound didn't have quite the richly textured decay I look forward to hearing from the instrument.

Apart from falling short on such things as the purr of a big piano, as described above, or the full harmonic complexity of the finest stringed instruments, the sonic presentation of the Moon i-7 was hard to fault. The i-7 could be exceeded more decisively—by amplifiers that are more expensive, less easy to use, or both—in the ability to convey a sense of flow and humanness from recorded music. If an audio amplifier exists as a sort of stencil for coaxing household electricity into a semblance of real music—and I suppose, in a sense, it does—then one must also acknowledge that most such things trace the music's outline in ways that lack nuance, and thus sound more mechanical than what they're trying to imitate. It's a rare amplifier that follows every curve sufficiently well to entirely fool the ear, and the i-7 doesn't make it to that level.

One last note: Not every solid-state amplifier can successfully drive the original Quad ESL electrostatic loudspeaker—especially not wide-bandwidth amps, which are flustered by the crazy dip in the ESL's impedance curve way up high. The Moon qualifies as a wide-bandwidth amp, yet it drove the Quads without complaint. In fact, the i-7 sounded better with the Quads than at least one otherwise lovely tube amplifier I've tried (itself a subject I'll return to in next month's "Listening"). The i-7 let the Quads sing with all the emotion they're known for, and kept their bass panels on a tight leash: The floor toms and electric bass in Lee Feldman's "Give Me My Money," from his brilliant I've Forgotten Everything (CD, Urban Myth UM-114-2), were tight'n'tuneful—much more so than when I listened to the same cut with my Quad II amps doing the honors—and the big bass drum in Michael Tilson Thomas's very nice recording of Mahler's Symphony 3 (SACD, San Francisco Symphony 821936-0003-2) never got out of control, although I suspect it wanted to.

Conclusions
As Fee Waybill of The Tubes sang on that group's eponymous debut: What do you want from life? A powerful amp that does no more or less than boost the signal it's given, for better or for worse? An amplifier that imbues all recorded music with an indefinable sense of artistic nuance and intensity? A meaningless love affair with a girl you just met tonight?

Simaudio's Moon Evolution i-7 is very good at one of those things.

Some reasonable comparisons: At $6000, the Moon i-7 is significantly more expensive than the Naim Nait 5i ($1425) and Cyrus 8vs ($1795), but offers more than both of those amps in terms of ergonomic refinements—not to mention sheer output power. The Moon is on a par with the best I've heard in terms of rhythm and pacing, yet offers a wider bandwidth. Various tubed integrated amps, ranging from the Primaluna Prologue One ($1195) to the curvaceous Viva Solista ($9900), offer a slightly better, more human sense of flow—not to mention extra personality, assuming that's what you want.

As an engineering accomplishment and objet d'art industriel, the Simaudio Moon Evolution i-7 is a success, and its price is a fair reflection of the effort required to make it real. It is also a safe buying recommendation for anyone who wants power, neutrality, and flexibility—and doesn't want to jump through hoops o' flame to get them. A lovely thing.

Related Links...

Read More...